“JOIN THE NAVY SEE THE WORLD!” – The Price of Dignity

There was a time in the last century when the armed forces became extremely unfashionable. A combination of the Swinging 60’s, the disaster that was the Vietnam War, slogans like ‘Make love not war’; all contributed to a general feeling that joining the forces was now seriously uncool. This also came about at the same time that the powers of advertising were starting to realise just how powerful they could be so the two parties sat down at the table. Advertising and the Armed Forces.

Numbers falling short – what do we do? A bit of mindbending might be in order…………

‘Why are numbers short ?’ The Armed Forces are no longer cool – Solution – make it cool. ‘What are people now interested in?’ Travel, a career, education, money. Perfect – we’ll give it to them. We’ll get them to understand/ comprehend/swallow that joining the Forces is an opportunity to do/have all these things. You’ll travel the world. You’ll learn skills that set you up for life when you leave. You’ll meet wonderful people, make lifelong friendships. You will be respected in society and most importantly you’ll have just as much (if not more) fun as those long-haired hippie-freak anti-war friends of yours. Sooooooooooooooooo

Fast forward to 2007.

Well we’re in a fine pickle aren’t we? It is very difficult to embarrass Morag and she is not given to bouts of extreme national feeling. However I am now embarrassed, ashamed and saddened. How and when did we become a nation where it is considered ok or fine for members of the Armed Forces to come home and sell their stories? And please don’t even waste my time or yours with statements like ‘well someone else would have made money out of it so why not they?’ There are many unseemly activities that will always be moneyspinners should we then indulge whenever the opportunity for a bit of quick cash arises? The logic that money would be made no matter what so therefore……..should be beneath us – that is what ethics, morals and standards are all about. Knowing when to say ‘actually this is not appropriate’.

Better we had stood up and said ‘well actually the MOD needs to get the general population onside and as no one believes them anymore after the Iraq debacle and in an effort to continue the propaganda let’s let the story come from the horses mouths’ (albeit from typewritten reams of foolscap). I am hoping against hope that this is the real reason this quell-and-tell was suggested or allowed. Yes it would be despicable and manipulative (where have we heard this before…..) but I guess even knowing that it is a propaganda exercise pure and simple would be better than this tacky and tawdry spectacle we are now beholding. And that is without delving into the content of the stories…………

“I was frightened”, “I feared for my life”……..I can’t even repeat any more. Of course the hell you were frightened. Yes being in that position if you had any sense you would be fearing for your life. But ‘I heard hammers and sawing and ………coffin’? That’s one step away from a branch falls on your roof and you ‘just know’ King Kong has landed and has come to get you.

For those of us who can remember the concept of armed forces before they got tarted up it was “Join the forces defend your country. Good chance of kill or be killed. Good chance of torture or be tortured.” None of this see the world, have fun crap. And that’s where the problem lies (in my mind) – we have become a nation of people (many of us, especially the under 60-s) who do not understand the real concept of what armed forces are supposed to do. It is a serious job, with serious downsides. I’ve been watching hostages for many a long year now and trust me – those were the ‘happiest’ hostages I’ve ever seen. Iranian propaganda? Well you know what – better a bit of chess and some five-a-side than what you see going on at Guantanamo Bay. Better cheap and nasty suits than orange jumpsuits and shackles. Better ‘fake’ smiles and laughter, than sacks over their heads.

Before the shouting starts let me be VERY CLEAR about something. My complaint is not with the sailors. My complaints are with the puppetmasters not the puppets.

My heartfelt sympathies go out to the families of soldiers and sailors who have been killed on duty. Families who sent their children off to be trained and then got a phonecall that they had ‘somehow accidentally killed themselves’. Sympathies to to all the families with stories they wanted the world to know but because the MOD didn’t feel them worthy of being told they live nowhere but in their hearts.

Now when the Powers That Be at the MOD sit around a table they will be able to use their calculators to add up what price our dignity as a nation was worth. And hopefully we as a nation don’t fall for it and these papers become what they deserve to be – yesterday’s chip-wrapping.

And yes welcome home to the sailors, and yes we are all pleased that you are home safely – this isn’t about you this is about they who pull your strings, and ours. We’ve had enough.



Filed under Uncategorized

10 responses to ““JOIN THE NAVY SEE THE WORLD!” – The Price of Dignity

  1. dolbyn

    here is a quick glib reply so that i can be the first to comment – yay –

    a) I suspect that the sailers would have lasted less than 2 weeks in the big brother house – i be shilppa would have had greater backbone

    b) i dont blame the 15 themselves , rather i blame theire superiors for letting them in the armed forces and for not better training them.

    ok now i will read what you actually wrote 🙂

  2. dolbyn

    ok read it – we agree 🙂

    i’ve not read any of the interviews in full rather have been skimming various blogs and news sources, so the following may be misreported…. The gifts they were given were not confiscated by the MOD but rather are on ebay.one of the sailors is complaining the iranians kept his iPod ( lets hope he wasnt playing it when captured ) Faye was seperated from the men and dealt with by other women who measured her for her suit, they told her she would not see her child again, the men were blindfolded and had their necks flicked and were threatened with prison.

    Faye said she was scared of being raped and the men seemd scared that they would be beheaded , “they had all seen the videos”. So in fact it seems the fears we sent them in with were far worse than the actual treatement they recieved. By painting the bogey man so scarily the west did more to break the 15 than the iranians ever did.

    Finally i dont know which is the more scary thought – that these 15 are typical of those who serve, of that the iranians just got very very lucky.

  3. dolbyn

    Roll on the summer when we have the next sporting event and we all get told that we cannot wave union jacks or st george crosses lest it offend anyone 😦

  4. A thoughtfully written piece and I agree with your sentiments.

    As I was on a North Sea Ferry for 3+ days last week I missed the media release-fest and I couldn’t get up the enthusiasm to read about it in the Sunday paper.

    I have to say that I don’t trust either Government to not lie about it, which is a sorry state of affairs.

  5. Ray

    Well said, Morag. May I also make the point that perhaps the MoD calculated that while we are all caught up in the issue of them selling their stories, our attention as a nation will be diverted from one very important question: how the blue blazes did they come to be captured in the first place?

  6. dolbyn

    Am sure questions about how they were capturd will be answerd in the movie 😉

  7. Pingback: Bel is thinking : Blog Archive : Links

  8. Virtually everybody is posting on the issue and my opinion is certainly firming along the lines you wrote. It’s a very strange saga altogether.

  9. Well written post. There is something very unsurprising about this episode. The most depressing part is that we can all be in agreement, but don’t believe that any of our leaders will take these matters by the scruff of their necks.

  10. Its good to see you make postings on this topic, I have to book mark this website. Keep up the good work.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s